Reconditioned vs. Second-Hand Engines: Which Should You Choose?

Name: All Good Parts
Brand: All Good Parts
Rating: 5 (33 reviews)

May 7, 2025

When your car engine gives out, the next big decision is whether to replace it with a reconditioned engine or a second-hand (used) engine. For many Australian drivers, this choice boils down to cost, reliability, and how quickly you need to get back on the road.

At All Good Parts, we specialize in high-quality used engines and are here to help you make the right choice. In this blog, we break down the key differences and explain why a second-hand engine might just be your best bet.

What Are Second-Hand (Used) Engines?

Used engines are removed from vehicles that have been written off but still have fully functional parts. These engines are:

Carefully dismantled and inspected
Sold with known mileage and condition reports
Much more affordable than reconditioned alternatives
Faster to source and install

If you’re looking for a cost-effective repair without compromising on quality, used engines are a smart and reliable solution.

Are Reconditioned Engines?

Reconditioned engines are taken apart, cleaned, and rebuilt with a mix of old and new parts. They often go through:

Replacement of worn-out components
Basic reassembly (depending on the reconditioner’s standards)
Resurfacing of internal parts

While they may appear newer, reconditioned engines can be more expensive and their reliability varies based on the skills and parts used by the rebuilder.

Why Used Engines Are Often the Smarter Choice

Here’s why thousands of Aussies choose used engines from trusted suppliers like All Good Parts:

Lower upfront costs with no hidden surprises
Quick availability – perfect for fast repairs
Sourced from reputable wreckers across Australia
Great for daily drivers who want value without paying for unnecessary overhauls

Common Myths About Used Engines – Debunked

Let’s clear up some misunderstandings:

Myth: Used engines are unreliable.
Truth: With proper sourcing and testing, used engines deliver strong performance.
Myth: They come with no warranty.
Truth: At All Good Parts, we offer a 3-month warranty on most used engines.
Myth: High mileage equals poor quality.
Truth: Many engines with moderate mileage are in excellent shape and run efficiently for years.

What to Look for When Buying a Used Engine

To get the best deal, make sure to check:

Mileage and internal condition
Compatibility (engine number and vehicle match)
The supplier’s reputation and return policy
Whether there’s a warranty or support offered

Our team at All Good Parts can help guide you through this process with expert advice and transparent listings.

Why Buy Used Engines from All Good Parts?

We’re more than just a supplier — we’re your trusted auto parts partner.

Wide inventory of used engines for all major makes and models
Fast, Australia-wide shipping
3-month warranty on most parts
Friendly experts to help match the right engine to your vehicle

Whether you drive a Toyota, Ford, BMW, or Mazda, we’ve got the right engine at the right price.

Final Thoughts

Reconditioned engines might sound appealing on paper, but they’re often overpriced and inconsistently built. If you want value, reliability, and speed, a high-quality second-hand engine from All Good Parts is the clear choice.